No comments about King George V.

No comments about Frederick I : The Man and His Times.

No comments about The New England Knight: Sir William Phips, 1651-1695.

5 comments about Hidden Agenda: How the Duke of Windsor Betrayed the Allies.

1. You attempt to contribute to the cover up for Edward VIII of England.
   
   He certainly thought it more important to marry a divorced American
   
   than remain King of his country in time of crisis. He also violated the
   
   integrity the Church of England of which he was the official head and
   
   protector.
   
   What about Lord Halifax and George VI in the early going?
   
   What about the Welsh coal miners who were already loosing too many
   
   lives because of an indifferent government and other English citizens
   
   who were about to put their lives and honor on the line to defend England
   
   against Nazi aggression?
   
   
   
   
   Wendell M Kury



2. Martin Allen`s book „Hidden Agenda - How the Duke of Windsor betrayed the Allies" provides us with an interesting look behind the stage on which the beginning of the Second World War was taking shape. Martin Allen describes in considerable detail the interests of the various parties involved in this conflict - the actors, the observers, and the by-standers, and he adroitly shows how some of the players, at times, would switch from one category to the other.

   The lynchpin of the book is a letter, supposedly written in late 1939 by the Duke. Its purpose was to introduce to Hitler the Duke`s messenger, the Franco-American industrial consultant, Charles E. Bedaux who, in those early months and years of the war, was able to travel quite freely from one side of the „Sitzkrieg" front to the other.

   A facsimile of the letter is shown in the book. Obviously, for a mere reader, it is impossible to say whether the letter is genuine or not. The (German!) text of the letter is, however, just ever so slightly off the track with respect to normal German style, grammar, and vocabulary that it may well have been written by a person, such as the Duke, whose command of the language was good, but not perfect. It would have taken an excellent forger to achieve such a convincing degree of (im)perfection.

   The immediate military results of the Duke`s overtures toward Hitler were twofold. They represent, in a way, each party`s ante in the bargain: the Duke`s information on the French defenses allowed the Germans to turn the „sitzkrieg" into a „blitzkrieg" in the summer of 1940, whereas the German contribution was to hold their panzers back when they reached the Channel, thus allowing the British Expeditionary Force to retreat from Dunkerque with acceptable losses.

   At this point, the book argues more or less explicitly, it would have been possible for some sort of peace deal to be reached. However, the Duke`s position at home had been undermined by internal machinations that had led to his resignation and he was unable to realize his ambition which, according to Allen, was to recover his throne through this admittedly risky alliance with Berlin.

   The obvious argument that comes to mind at this point is that any peace with Hitler would have constituted an abandonment of Poland for whose integrity and protection the Allies had, after all, gone to war. We must realize, though, that at the end of September, 1939, when the war in Poland had come to its rapid end, the Germans had occupied only the western half of that country. The eastern half of Poland was, by then, under Soviet domination, because the Soviets had, on 17 September 1939 (when the victory of their German ally was evident) sent in the Red Army to take over the rest - and to hold on to it to the present day.

   This overt act of aggression did not cause a stir in the Allied camp and voids the argument sketched out above. The value of Allen`s book lies in its exposure of the duplicity of the policy of the Allies. Only five years later, the world witnessed and for the most part, welcomed the complete hand-over of Poland and the rest of Eastern Europe to Stalin who, by that time, had become the West`s most valuable ally in the fight for the ideals of freedom and democracy. It took History a mere fifty years and millions of dead to rectify that situation. One wonders if the price that might have had to be paid to Hitler would have been quite as high as that.




3. This book charges that the Duke of Windsor, formerly King Edward VIII, gave Allied military secrets to Germany in a deliberate scheme to help the Nazis against his own country.

   The British establishment, the author says, used Edward's love for Wallis Simpson as a pretext to force his abdication because of his pro-German views. Then, he says, that same establishment used Edward to spy on French military installations for Britain--but that Edward simultaneously passed the secrets along to the Germans through Charles Bedaux, a shadowy character with ties to both Edward and Adolf Hitler.

   The book is built around a handwritten letter, in German, from Edward to Hitler, which the author says his father received years later from Hitler's architect, Albert Speer. The book surmises that Edward gave the letter to Bedaux, who hid it in his hat band, or elsewhere, and then personally delivered it to Hitler.

   On the surface the letter is cryptic. Was Edward really trying to hurt Britain--or help Hitler put him back on the Throne? Was he being solicitous, or devious? If the circumstances surrounding the letter are indeed what the author claims, then this book has a real story to tell.

   Unfortunately, the book's shortcomings as a serious history cast doubt on its conclusions. There is some original research, particularly with respect to the background of Bedaux himself. Most of the text, however, rests either on secondary sources or on no acknowledged source at all. The author does not cite the particular pages of the secondary sources, so it is virtually impossible for readers to evaluate the information for themselves. Worse yet, many highly accusatory and critical passages have no source references whatsoever, leaving frustrated readers to wonder whether the undocumented conversations and events actually happened. The overall tone suggests that the author has let his own animus toward Edward dictate the scholarship, rather than the other way around.

   The author explains that many of the primary source documents have been destroyed, are not available for inspection, or are perhaps even being hidden by the British royal family itself. That, though, is not a license to make critical assumptions that result, essentially, in a charge of treason.

   The letter appears to bear Edward's handwriting, as far as one can tell from the lithographic reproduction in the book. In an appendix the author recounts that a handwriting expert authenticated the letter. Sadly, however, he does not identify the expert, and the glaring absence of the expert's identity further undermines this book's claims.

   Even if the letter is genuine, it does not prove the author's thesis. Edward was not anti-German, and he may well have thought that the Nazis were Europe's best defense against Soviet expansionism. He may also have been careless in his dealings with both Bedaux and Hitler. But that certainly does not mean that Edward would deliberately seek to harm the Empire that he served so long as Prince of Wales, and later as King.

   The overreaching premise of this book makes the story of royal intrigue entertaining, but one should not uncritically accept all of the story.




4. This most biased reflection of Charles Eugene Bedaux demonstrates an underlying bias on the part of the Autoho. Unsubstantiated facts based upon Allen's prejudice are slanderous and if Bedaux were still alive, he would have set the record sttraight and possibly involved many prominent US citizens. Bedaux did much to styme the Naxi operarionf in France and this is totally ignored in this book.



5. This book gets one star simply for its value to take space on a bookshelf! Otherwise, some of the probably accurate conslusions about the Duke of Windsor are rendered suspect by Martin Allen's faulty and obviously ill-researched and biased conclusions regarding Charles Eugene Bedeaux!

   I have studied and researched Bedeaux for several years now. Allen would have done well to talk with the few surviving Frenchmen in and around Tour that knew of Bedeaux's efforts in putting kinks in all Nazi manufacturing ans ship-building production in France under his direction.

   Jim Christy's book, "The Price of Power, The Story of Charles Eugene Bedeaux", more accurately concludes that Bedaux may certainly have courted the Duke for his "star power" of the day and that Bedeaux was NOT a Nazi collaborator but rather worked skillfully to sabotage wartime production in France that could have greatly benefitted the Nazi powers.

   Allen appears more inclined to follow his own "conclusions" that are far from conclusive. It is my opinion that Bedeaux took his own life, probably with some relief by many powerful Americans, and with perhaps aid from his captors. Had he lived and told the entire story, too many powerful US citizens would have become involved.

   Sadly, this flawed tale could have been told better with adequate research and less unproven ideas expressed as fact.

   Find Jim Christy's book for a much better-told tale and much, much more accuracy.

No comments about The Gardens of Queen Elizabeth the Queen Mother: A Personal Tour with the Marchioness of Salisbury.

No comments about Monarch: The Life and Times of Elizabeth II (Thorndike Large Print Popular Series).

1 comments about The Jahangirnama: Memoirs of Jahangir, Emperor of India.

1. I would recommend this book for serious folks interested in the art of Mogul Miniatures. Jahangir was a very special king and this book sheds light on the magic of the time period. It is a big and physically heavy book but such a joy to read. You can glimpse into the interests and lives of the royality and experience their lives in detail. The authors have gone into alot of research and there are many descriptions to dates, calendar, language and art. The book itself is a work of art. The reproductions of the miniature paintings, including many portraits of the royal court, are excellent. It is about time that art such as this is understood, recognized and appreciated. This book leads the way.

1 comments about William: The People's Prince: His Life in Pictures (Nunn Syndication Books).

1. I have been following the life of Prince William since his birth (though not fanatically) and thought this book looked like it might bring some new light to the boy who became a man the moment he walked behind his mother's coffin that sad day in 1997. The information in the book covers all of William's formative years all the way up to present day, but the main reason to purchase the book is for the photgraphs. Several are never-before seen (at least by me) and the up-close shots are bright, crisp and clear. You get a feel for this young man who must learn step-by-step on how to handle the press without turning them against you (surely no easy task and one neither of his parents ever fully accomplished, though there may be hope for Charles). I read the book in one day since the early information was not new to me and savored the pictures. I came away with a new appreciation for the unique position Prince William has and a hope that he finds the happiness in life that has eluded Charles and that Diana seemed on just the verge of finding.

No comments about Lives and Letters of the Devereux, Earls of Essex: In the Reigns of Elizabeth, James I, and Charles I, 1540-1646. Volume 2.

1 comments about Edward, Prince of Wales and Aquitaine: A Biography of the Black Prince.

1. If you're looking for an upbeat, easy-to-read history of Prince Edward, look elsewhere. This is definitely NOT the book for you.
   
   If you are looking for a book that details the life of a great leader, and digs deeply into the machinations behind the events of his times, this is definitely the book to get.
   
   So, point of the review: Armchair historians beware! This is a deep, quite dry history of the Black Prince.